Learning to play the piano is an exciting journey, but one of the first decisions aspiring pianists face is whether to take formal piano lessons or go down the self-taught route. With the rise of online tutorials, apps, and self-guided courses, teaching yourself to play the piano has never been more accessible. However, working with a professional piano tutor offers structure and personalised guidance that self-learning often lacks. So, which is the best option for you? Let's explore the advantages and disadvantages of both methods.

The Benefits Of Learning With A Piano Tutor

Hiring a piano tutor remains one of the most effective ways to learn the instrument. Here are some of the main benefits:

1. Structured Learning And Progression

A professional tutor will create a structured learning plan tailored to your ability and goals. They can ensure you master fundamental techniques before progressing to more advanced pieces, reducing the risk of developing bad habits.

2. Immediate Feedback And Corrections

One of the key benefits of taking piano lessons is receiving instant feedback. A tutor can correct mistakes in technique, hand positioning, and posture in real time, helping you improve more efficiently.

3. Motivation And Accountability

Regular lessons with a tutor help keep students motivated. Having someone to guide you and hold you accountable ensures steady progress, making it less likely that you will become frustrated and give up.

4. Access To A Wider Range Of Music

A tutor can introduce you to different musical styles and genres, expanding your knowledge and helping you become a more versatile pianist. They can also recommend pieces suited to your skill level, keeping your learning experience engaging and challenging.

5. Preparation For Exams And Performances

If you aim to take graded music exams or perform publicly, working with a tutor is invaluable. They can help you prepare for assessments, refine your technique, and build confidence in your abilities.

The Drawbacks Of Learning With A Piano Tutor

While learning with a tutor has many advantages, it does come with some downsides:

• Cost: Private piano lessons can be expensive, particularly if taken regularly.
• Scheduling: Fixed lesson times may not always fit your lifestyle, especially if you have a busy schedule.
• Dependence on a teacher: Some students may become overly reliant on their tutor rather than developing self-sufficiency in their learning.

The Benefits Of Teaching Yourself Piano

With modern technology, teaching yourself piano is more feasible than ever. Here are some of the advantages:

1. Flexible Learning Schedule

One of the biggest perks of self-learning is the ability to practice whenever it suits you. There’s no need to adhere to a fixed lesson schedule, making it ideal for those with irregular routines.

2. Cost-Effective

Self-teaching is often more affordable than hiring a tutor. Many online resources, apps, and YouTube tutorials are free or available at a lower cost than in-person lessons.

3. Learn At Your Own Pace

Self-learning allows you to progress at a comfortable speed. You can spend more time on challenging sections without feeling pressured to keep up with a tutor’s lesson plan.

4. Wide Range Of Learning Resources

There are countless online tutorials, sheet music websites, and interactive apps like Simply Piano or Flowkey that make learning accessible to anyone with a piano or keyboard.

The Drawbacks Of Teaching Yourself

While self-teaching has its benefits, there are some potential downsides to consider:

• Lack of structure: Without a tutor, it can be difficult to follow a structured learning path, leading to gaps in knowledge and technique.
• No immediate feedback: Without expert guidance, you may develop poor habits that could hinder your progress in the long run.
• Less motivation: Without a teacher to hold you accountable, it can be easy to lose motivation or skip practice sessions.
• Limited understanding of Music Theory: Many self-taught pianists focus on playing songs rather than learning music theory, which can limit their overall musical development.

Which Option Is Best For You?

Ultimately, the choice between piano lessons and self-teaching depends on your learning style, goals, and budget. If you’re looking for structured guidance, faster progress, and expert feedback, investing in a piano tutor may be the best route. However, if you’re motivated, disciplined, and prefer a flexible learning approach, self-teaching can be highly rewarding - especially if you already play another instrument. Remember, it doesn’t have to be as black and white as piano lessons or self-taught: the best option overall could be a mix of both!

If you're considering working with a tutor, check out our recommended piano instructors at The Music Depot. Whether you choose professional lessons or the self-taught route, the most important thing is to enjoy the process and keep playing!

FAQs

1. Can you teach yourself piano, or is it better to take piano lessons?

You can teach yourself piano, but it requires self-discipline and patience. Piano lessons are better for structured guidance, fast progression and avoiding bad habits.

2. Are piano lessons or self-taught methods more effective for beginners?

Piano lessons are generally more effective for beginners, offering a strong foundation in technique and theory. Self-teaching can work but may lead to slower progress and poor habits.

3. What are the pros and cons of piano lessons vs. teaching yourself?

Lessons offer structured learning and quick feedback but come with time and cost commitments. Self-teaching is flexible and affordable but can lack direction and immediate correction. 

4. How much do private piano lessons cost?

Private piano lessons typically cost between £25 to £60 per hour, depending on the teacher's experience and location. Rates may be higher in major cities like London. Some teachers also offer discounts for group lessons.

5. What is the best way to teach yourself piano if you skip formal lessons?

Start with basic music theory and use online tutorials or apps. Focus on mastering one skill at a time and regularly assess your progress. Be patient as self-teaching may take longer than lessons.

When deciding between a keyboard and a digital piano, it can be difficult to determine which is better suited for your needs. Though they may appear similar at first glance, there are distinct differences in their physical attributes, sound quality, price range, and the skill level required to play each. Understanding these differences will help you choose the instrument that’s perfect for you so let’s dive in!

Physical Differences

One of the most noticeable differences between a keyboard and a digital piano lies in their design and size. Keyboards are typically lightweight and portable, making them an ideal choice for musicians who need an instrument they can easily carry or store. They often have fewer keys, usually 61 or 76, compared to the standard 88 keys found on a digital piano.

Digital pianos, on the other hand, are designed to replicate the feel and appearance of an acoustic piano. They are usually larger and heavier, often housed in wooden cabinets . This makes them less portable but more suitable as a permanent fixture in a home or studio (although portable versions are available). Additionally, digital pianos often feature fully weighted or semi-weighted keys to simulate the resistance and response of an acoustic piano, offering a more authentic playing experience.

Sound Quality

Sound quality is another major distinction between keyboards and digital pianos. Keyboards are versatile instruments capable of producing a wide range of sounds, from pianos and strings to drums and synthesizers. This makes them ideal for musicians looking to experiment with different styles and genres. However, the sound quality of keyboards can vary significantly depending on the model and price point, and many entry-level keyboards use basic sound engines that may lack richness and realism.

Digital pianos are specifically designed to emulate the sound of an acoustic piano. They use advanced sampling technology to replicate the nuances of a traditional piano, including the sustain and resonance of the strings. High-end digital pianos may even include features like graded hammer action and sound modelling, ensuring a highly realistic experience. If you prioritise authentic piano sounds, a digital piano is likely the better choice.

Price Range

The price difference between keyboards and digital pianos is another factor to consider. Keyboards are generally more affordable, with entry-level models available for as little as £55 to £100. Even mid-range keyboards with additional features are available for around £500, making them accessible for beginners or casual players.

Digital pianos, however, are a more significant investment. Prices typically start at around £300 for basic models and can exceed £4,000 for high-end instruments with advanced features. The higher cost reflects their superior sound quality, build, and features designed to closely mimic an acoustic piano.

Skill Level Required

The skill level required to play a keyboard versus a digital piano depends largely on your goals as a musician. Keyboards are often favoured by beginners due to their affordability, portability, and simple features. Many keyboards also include learning tools, such as built-in tutorials and light-up keys, to help novices get started.

Digital pianos, with their weighted keys and acoustic-like feel, are better suited for players who aim to develop proper piano technique. While beginners can certainly start with a digital piano, the realistic touch and sound are particularly beneficial for intermediate and advanced players who want to transition to or from an acoustic piano.

Which Instrument Is Right for You?

Choosing between a keyboard and a digital piano depends on your personal preferences, budget, and musical aspirations. If you’re a beginner looking for a versatile, affordable, and portable option, a keyboard may be the way to go. However, if you’re serious about learning or want a more authentic piano-playing experience, investing in a digital piano is a wise decision.

By considering the physical differences, sound quality, price, and skill requirements, you can make an informed choice and enjoy the instrument that best suits your needs. Whether you opt for the adaptability of a keyboard or the realism of a digital piano, both can provide endless hours of musical enjoyment.

You can browse our full range of pianos and keyboards here.

FAQ

Can I learn to play the piano on a keyboard?
Yes, many beginners start with a keyboard because of its affordability and ease of use. However, if your goal is to eventually play an acoustic piano, a digital piano may be a better choice for developing proper technique.

Are digital pianos louder than keyboards?
Both digital pianos and keyboards typically include volume controls and headphone jacks. However, digital pianos usually have more powerful speakers, resulting in richer, more resonant sound.

How many keys should a beginner’s keyboard have?
A beginner’s keyboard typically has 61 or 76 keys, which are sufficient for learning basic techniques and songs. However, advanced players may prefer the full 88 keys.

Do digital pianos require tuning?
No, digital pianos do not require tuning as they use digital sound samples instead of strings.

Which is more durable, a keyboard or a digital piano?
Digital pianos are generally more durable due to their robust build, but keyboards can last a long time with proper care and maintenance.

When it comes to buying a piano, there really is something for everyone. Whether you’re a professional musician, a beginner, or someone looking for the perfect blend of features and value, you’ll find the right instrument to suit your needs. In this roundup, we’ve categorised the best pianos as of 2024 to make your decision-making process seamless.

Best for Professionals: Yamaha TC3 TransAcoustic Piano

The Yamaha TC3 TransAcoustic Piano is a masterpiece of modern engineering. Designed for the discerning pianist, this model combines the authentic sound and touch of a traditional acoustic piano with advanced digital features.

Key Features:

• TransAcoustic Technology: Allows you to play with headphones while retaining the natural acoustic resonance.
• Unmatched Sound Quality: The soundboard amplifies digital sounds for a rich, immersive experience.
• Connectivity: Bluetooth and app integration enable effortless control over settings and access to additional features.

With its seamless blend of acoustic and digital elements, the Yamaha TC3 is perfect for professional performers and recording artists who demand versatility and top-notch sound.

Best Value for Money: Casio AP750 Digital Piano

The Casio AP750 Digital Piano stands out as an exceptional choice for those who want quality without breaking the bank. While it’s priced affordably, it doesn’t compromise on performance or features.

Key Features:

• Scaled Hammer Action Keys: Replicates the feel of a traditional piano.
• Wide Sound Library: Over 250 tones and rhythms to explore.
• Compact Design: Perfect for smaller spaces without sacrificing sound quality.

Whether you’re a beginner or an intermediate player, the AP750 delivers exceptional value with its reliable performance and robust feature set.

Most Features: Yamaha CLP 875 Digital Piano

For those who want it all, the Yamaha CLP 875 Digital Piano is a technological marvel packed with innovative features. It’s ideal for tech-savvy musicians who want to experiment with a range of sounds and capabilities.

Key Features:

• GrandTouch Keyboard: Provides an authentic playing experience akin to a concert grand piano.
• Binaural Sampling: Creates a 3D soundscape when using headphones.
• Smart Pianist App: Enables easy control and offers tutorials to enhance your learning experience.

With its combination of advanced digital features and high-quality sound reproduction, the CLP 875 is a standout model for anyone looking to push their musical boundaries.

Best for Acoustic Purists: Yamaha B3 Acoustic Piano

If you’re a traditionalist at heart, the Yamaha B3 Acoustic Piano is a timeless classic. Renowned for its impeccable craftsmanship and unmatched tonal quality, the B3 is an excellent choice for both serious students and professional pianists.

Key Features:

• Solid Spruce Soundboard: Ensures clear, resonant tones.
• Sturdy Build: Built to last, with excellent tuning stability.
• Elegant Design: A stunning addition to any home or studio.

The Yamaha B3 is a no-frills acoustic piano that delivers exceptional sound and durability, making it a worthwhile investment for those who value tradition.

Best for Modern Living: Roland LX6 Digital Piano

The Roland LX6 Digital Piano is perfect for the modern musician who values aesthetics, compactness, and superior technology. It’s the ultimate choice for contemporary living spaces where functionality and style are equally important.

Key Features:

• SuperNATURAL Modelling Technology: Produces rich, authentic piano sounds without sampling.
• Slim, Stylish Design: Fits seamlessly into any room.
• Bluetooth Audio and MIDI: Offers wireless connectivity for seamless integration with other devices.

With its sleek design and cutting-edge technology, the LX6 is the go-to piano for modern households.

The best piano for you ultimately depends on your needs and budget. Professionals might gravitate towards the Yamaha TC3 for its versatility, while beginners and value-seekers will love the Casio AP750. If you’re looking for the latest in digital innovation, the Yamaha CLP 875 and Roland LX6 are outstanding choices. And for those who cherish the classics, the Yamaha B3 Acoustic Piano remains a stellar option. 

You can view our pianos online here, but some models, such as The Casio AP750 and Roland LX6 are currently only available in store, so to see for yourself how good they are, and to get some advice from our resident experts, come down to Fore Street in Exeter and visit The Music Depot!

FAQ

What should I consider when buying a piano? Look for a model that suits your skill level, budget, and space requirements. Consider whether you prefer acoustic or digital and check for features like connectivity and sound quality.

Are digital pianos as good as acoustic pianos? Digital pianos offer versatility, features, and the convenience of silent practice. While they can’t fully replicate the feel of an acoustic, top models like the Yamaha CLP 875 come close.

What is TransAcoustic technology? TransAcoustic technology combines acoustic piano elements with digital capabilities, offering the best of both worlds. It allows for silent practice and digital sound manipulation.

Which piano is best for beginners? The Casio AP750 is an excellent choice for beginners, offering affordability, ease of use, and great sound quality.

Can I play these pianos with headphones? Yes, most digital models, including the Yamaha TC3, Yamaha CLP 875, and Roland LX6, feature headphone compatibility for silent practice.

If you're interested in learning a new instrument or upgrading your musical setup, you might be asking yourself: Should I buy a piano or a keyboard? This is a common question for beginners, and the answer depends on several factors, including your goals, budget, and lifestyle. Here, we'll look at the pros and cons of both options, taking into consideration sound, versatility, portability, cost, and learning curve, to help you make the right decision.

Sound Quality

One of the biggest differences between a piano and a keyboard is sound quality.

• Piano: The sound of an acoustic piano is rich, deep, and authentic. Each key strike triggers a hammer that hits a string, producing a warm and resonant sound. If you're a classical music enthusiast or someone who values the finest musical experience, a piano might be the better choice.
• Keyboard: While keyboards have come a long way in replicating piano sounds, they still can't match the full depth of a real piano. However, higher-end digital keyboards often offer samples of real pianos, and many come with various sound settings that allow you to mimic other instruments.

Versatility

When it comes to versatility, keyboards have the upper hand.

• Keyboard: With a keyboard, you're not just limited to one sound. You can experiment with various tones, from electric pianos to organs, synthesisers, and even non-musical sounds like percussion. Many keyboards also come with built-in effects and features such as layering, recording, and rhythm tracks. This makes keyboards excellent for anyone looking to dabble in different genres of music or create unique compositions.
• Piano: While the acoustic piano excels in delivering its pure, unadulterated sound, it's limited to just that — the piano. For those solely focused on mastering the rich library of piano pieces and enjoying classical or jazz music, this limitation might not be a problem. However, if you want to explore other sounds, you’ll find the piano quite restricted.

Portability

Portability is a significant factor to consider, especially if you're short on space or plan to move your instrument frequently.

• Keyboard: Keyboards are lightweight and portable. They come in various sizes, with 61, 76, or 88 keys, making it easy to find one that fits your space and portability needs. You can even carry it to gigs or rehearsals without much hassle. Plus, most keyboards come with a headphone jack, so you can practise quietly without disturbing others.
• Piano: Acoustic pianos, on the other hand, are large and heavy. They require a dedicated space in your home and are difficult to move once set up. If you live in a small apartment or frequently change locations, a piano might not be practical unless you opt for a digital piano, which offers some level of portability but lacks the full acoustic experience.

Cost

Budget is often a major deciding factor when choosing between a piano and a keyboard.

• Piano: A good-quality acoustic piano is a considerable investment. Prices for new upright pianos can start from £3,000 and go well beyond £10,000 for grand pianos. Pianos also require regular tuning and maintenance, which adds to the overall cost.
• Keyboard: Keyboards, on the other hand, are much more affordable. You can find entry-level models for under £100, with higher-end digital pianos ranging up to £4000 or more. There's also minimal upkeep with keyboards, as they don’t need tuning, and repairs are generally simpler and cheaper.

Learning Curve

The learning experience can vary depending on whether you're playing a piano or a keyboard.

• Piano: The piano’s fully-weighted keys provide a better tactile response, which can improve finger strength and technique for beginners. It also forces learners to develop a proper touch and feel for dynamics (how hard or soft you play). Many professional musicians recommend learning on an acoustic piano because it helps build solid foundational skills.
• Keyboard: Most keyboards have lighter, semi-weighted keys or even unweighted keys, which are easier to press down but don’t offer the same physical feedback as a piano. This can make learning easier at the start but could hinder the development of technique if you eventually switch to a traditional piano. Some higher-end keyboards offer weighted keys to replicate the feel of a piano, striking a good balance between ease of learning and developing proper technique.

So, should you buy a piano or a keyboard? It really comes down to your personal needs and preferences. If you’re after the most authentic sound and playing experience and have the space and budget for it, a piano is the way to go. However, if you’re looking for a more affordable, portable, and versatile option, a keyboard might be the better choice.

Whatever you choose, both instruments offer immense satisfaction and can open up a world of musical possibilities.

You can browse our fantastic range of pianos and keyboards here.

FAQs

Can I learn piano on a keyboard?
Yes, many people start learning piano on a keyboard. However, it’s recommended to use a keyboard with weighted keys to simulate the feel of a real piano.

What’s the best keyboard for beginners?
A 61-key keyboard with semi-weighted keys is often recommended for beginners as it provides a good balance between playability and affordability.

Do pianos need regular maintenance?
Yes, acoustic pianos need tuning at least once or twice a year, along with occasional servicing to keep them in top shape.

Is a digital piano the same as a keyboard?
A digital piano is a type of keyboard that focuses on replicating the sound and feel of an acoustic piano, while a keyboard offers more sound variety and features.

Which is more affordable, a piano or a keyboard?
Keyboards are generally much more affordable, with models starting as low as £100. Acoustic pianos are significantly more expensive and require ongoing maintenance.

Embarking on the journey to learn piano is an exciting adventure, but choosing the right instrument can be daunting, especially with the wide variety of options available! The piano you select can significantly impact your learning experience, so it’s essential to find a model that suits your needs and budget. 

For beginners, digital pianos are often the most practical choice due to their affordability, portability, and low maintenance. 

Below, we explore three excellent digital pianos from our range at the Music Depot that are perfect for beginners, each offering a balance of quality and value across different price ranges.

Yamaha P145 Digital Piano – Affordable Quality

For those just starting, the Yamaha P145 Digital Piano is an excellent entry-level choice. Part of Yamaha's renowned P series, the P145 offers a full-sized, 88-key keyboard with weighted touch, mimicking the feel of an acoustic piano. 

This model is known for its simple controls and compact size, making it one of the best pianos for beginners who want to focus on the fundamentals without getting overwhelmed by advanced features.

The P145's portability is another plus—it can be placed on a tabletop, an X-frame keyboard stand, or Yamaha's L100 fixed wooden stand, which is available for £129. 

Priced at just £369, this piano delivers incredible value for its quality, making it a fantastic option for those who want a solid start without breaking the bank.

Yamaha P225 Digital Piano – Enhanced Features

If you're looking for something a bit more advanced but still beginner-friendly, the Yamaha P225 Digital Piano is a great step up from the P145. Priced at £549, this model offers everything the P145 does but with additional features that enhance the playing experience.

The P225 includes a newly developed Grand Hammer Compact keyboard action and a larger 2-way speaker system for richer sound. It also comes with 24 built-in instrument tones, including the Yamaha CFX grand piano tone found in higher-end models like the Clavinova. 

For those interested in expanding their setup, we offer a bundle that includes Yamaha’s official L200 fixed stand and L1B pedal system for £749. 

The P225 provides a more dynamic playing experience, making it one of the best pianos for beginners who want a bit more versatility in their instrument.

Yamaha CLP725 Digital Piano – Premium Beginner Option

For those willing to invest in a high-quality instrument, the Yamaha CLP725 Digital Piano is the first model in Yamaha's esteemed Clavinova range, offering a luxurious playing experience at £1099. This piano is designed with a full-size cabinet, an improved GrandTouch-S keyboard, and a triple pedal board, providing a feel that closely resembles an acoustic grand piano.

The CLP725 also features a 20W stereo speaker system, ensuring that the sound is as rich and immersive as the playing experience. It includes the prestigious Yamaha CFX and Bosendorfer grand piano tones as its default sounds, offering a level of quality typically reserved for much more expensive instruments. 

Despite its advanced features, the CLP725 remains approachable for beginners, with simple controls and settings. Additionally, this model comes with a 5-year warranty, giving you peace of mind as you embark on your musical journey.

Selecting the best piano for beginners depends largely on your budget and personal preferences. The Yamaha P145, P225, and CLP725 each offer something unique, whether it’s affordability, enhanced features, or a more premium experience, but any of these will serve you well as you are starting out.

All three models are available here at The Music Depot, so please come by if you want to see these fantastic pianos up close before you buy. Whichever model you choose, you can be confident that you’re starting your piano journey with a quality instrument that will support your growth as a musician.

You can browse our full range of pianos here.