Electric or Acoustic Guitar: Where Should You Start?

Starting out on a musical journey with the guitar is an exciting choice. One of the first decisions you’ll face is whether to start with an electric or an acoustic guitar. This is a question that comes up frequently among beginners, and while both options are fantastic, each has unique qualities. 

Here, we’ll help you weigh the pros and cons of electric and acoustic guitars so you can make an informed choice that suits your musical style, learning pace, and budget.

Price Comparison: What Can You Expect to Spend?

When it comes to price, both electric and acoustic guitars can range from affordable to high-end. However, for beginners, a decent entry-level acoustic guitar can generally be found at a slightly lower price point than an electric guitar setup.

A basic acoustic guitar package might cost between £100 and £200. For a beginner, this can be a straightforward and budget-friendly choice, as an acoustic guitar doesn’t require additional equipment like an amplifier.

On the other hand, a good entry-level electric guitar will cost a little bit more, but you’ll also need to purchase an amplifier and a cable, which adds to the overall expense. A complete electric guitar setup might therefore start around £200 to £300. While both options have affordable beginner kits available, if budget is a key consideration, an acoustic guitar could be the more economical choice.

Learning Curve: Which is Easier for Beginners?

It’s important to consider how easy an instrument is to learn, as you don’t want to be put off your musical journey just because you aren’t rockstar quality from the beginning. 

An acoustic guitar can often be simpler. With fewer components and no additional setup needed, beginners can focus purely on the mechanics of playing, without having to worry about different settings on your guitar or the amp. 

The slightly heavier strings and higher action (distance between the strings and the fretboard) on an acoustic guitar may initially be harder on your fingers, but it also helps build finger strength. Many guitarists believe that learning on an acoustic guitar first helps develop solid foundational skills, making it easier to transition to electric later.

Electric guitars, in contrast, have lighter strings and a lower action, which can make them easier to play. Bending notes and pressing chords typically require less pressure, which can be a big help for new players. Additionally, electric guitars offer volume control, so you can practise quietly with headphones if needed. If you’re drawn to genres like rock or metal, starting with an electric guitar might feel more motivating. 

However, bear in mind that an electric guitar involves some technical elements, such as adjusting the amp settings, which may add a bit of a learning curve. You may also find it difficult to transition if you want to switch to an acoustic later, due to the increased finger strength required as well as the different string spacing.

Equipment and Portability

An acoustic guitar’s all-in-one design makes it incredibly convenient and portable. You won’t need any additional equipment to get started (except maybe a case) —just tune up and play. This makes it a great option if you’re planning to practise in different locations, travel with your guitar, or don’t want to worry about setup. 

With an electric guitar, you’ll need an amplifier, cable, and perhaps some effects pedals to get your desired sound. This can make an electric setup less portable and more complex, especially for beginners who may feel overwhelmed by the extra equipment. That said, many modern amps offer built-in effects and headphone options, which are beneficial for practising at home without disturbing others.

Sound: Finding the Right Style for You

The sound of an acoustic guitar is warm, natural, and well-suited for genres like folk, blues, and pop. If you’re interested in singer-songwriter style music or strumming along to your favourite songs, an acoustic guitar might be more appealing. Acoustics offer a rich, resonant tone and are perfect for playing solo, as they don’t require amplification, although electro-acoustic models do give you the option of playing with an amp, which might be necessary when playing to a larger crowd or in a busy venue.

Electric guitars, however, shine when it comes to versatility. With an amplifier, you can experiment with a wide range of tones and effects, from clean and jazzy sounds to heavily distorted rock riffs. If your interest leans towards rock, punk, or any genre that relies on heavier sounds, an electric guitar might be more inspiring. The ability to experiment with tones can keep you engaged, but be aware that finding the right sound requires time and some technical understanding.

Should You Learn One Before the Other?

There’s no rule that says you must start with one type of guitar before transitioning to the other. However, some guitarists believe that learning on an acoustic guitar first builds strong finger technique and finger strength, which makes the transition to electric guitar easier down the line. 

An electro-acoustic guitar can be a good option if you intend to transition to electric later on, as you will develop the finger strength and technique required for an acoustic guitar, but you also have the option of playing around with different amp settings.

Others argue that electric guitars, with their lighter strings, are more beginner-friendly and less physically demanding, allowing new players to focus on technique without worrying about sore fingers.

Ultimately, the choice between acoustic and electric guitar is personal. Think about the type of music you enjoy, your budget, and how you envision your guitar-playing journey. Both options have their strengths, and either can serve as an excellent foundation for your musical adventure.

Choosing between an acoustic and an electric guitar can feel overwhelming, but it really comes down to personal preference and what inspires you. If you love the idea of an all-in-one, budget-friendly option, an acoustic guitar might be the perfect starting point. If the allure of a versatile, amplified sound appeals to you, go electric. 

Both instruments offer a fantastic way to start your guitar-playing journey, and there’s always the option to switch or add the other type to your collection in the future.

If you would like more advice, or you are ready to start browsing for your first guitar, come and visit us at The Music Depot, where one of our experts will be happy to assist you.

FAQ

Is an acoustic or electric guitar better for beginners?
Both have their advantages. Acoustic guitars are straightforward and affordable, while electric guitars are easier on the fingers and more versatile in sound.

Which is cheaper: acoustic or electric guitar?
Acoustic guitars are usually cheaper as they don’t require an amplifier. Electric guitar setups, including an amp and cables, can be more costly.

Can I play rock music on an acoustic guitar?
While acoustic guitars don’t offer the same range of effects, you can still play rock music. However, for a heavy sound, an electric guitar is generally preferred.

Do I need to learn acoustic guitar before electric?
No, you can start with either. Some believe that learning on an acoustic builds finger strength, but it’s fine to begin on electric if that’s your preference.

What extra equipment do I need for an electric guitar?
Besides the guitar, you’ll need an amplifier, a cable, and possibly a strap and picks. Some players also add effects pedals for more sound variety.